Re: BUG #18971: Server passes an invalid (indirect) path in PGDATA to the external program

Hello Tom,

> I do not think this is a Postgres bug.  The PGDATA environment
> variable is not canonical, it is just the default to be used if
> you don't specify a -D switch on the postmaster/pg_ctl command line.
> In fact, it might not be set at all.  (I see that pg_ctl does set
> it, but pg_ctl is not the only way to start the postmaster.)
> Therefore, relying on PGDATA in a restore_command script isn't safe.
> You should be relying on the current working directory (PWD) instead.
A test executes pg_ctl with the correct path to cluster and the correct CWD.

pg_ctl (and so on) executes an external program with inconsistent PGDATA 
and CWD.

This is clearly a problem on your side )

I wonder that it was not detected earlier.

For my point of view, if you can't provider a valid path in PGDATA, do 
not do it at all.

With Best Regards,

Dmitry Kovalenko