Deadlock between concurrent index builds on different tables
Jeremy Finzel <finzelj@gmail.com>
From: Jeremy Finzel <finzelj@gmail.com>
To: Postgres General <pgsql-general@postgresql.org>
Date: 2017-12-22T21:53:25Z
Lists: pgsql-general
I am attempting to build several indexes in parallel, guaranteeing that I never build one on the same table twice. I understand I can't build two on the same table at once or I will get a deadlock. However, I am also getting a deadlock when doing several in parallel on different tables. Here is an example of the error I am getting: 2017-12-22 15:48:07.669 CST,"CREATE INDEX",2017-12-22 15:48:02 CST,8/32,0,ERROR,40P01,"deadlock detected","Process 4470 waits for ShareLock on virtual transaction 4/262; blocked by process 4466. Process 4466 waits for ShareLock on virtual transaction 8/32; blocked by process 4470. Process 4470: CREATE INDEX CONCURRENTLY index_foo_on_created_at ON foo USING btree (created_at); Process 4466: CREATE INDEX CONCURRENTLY index_bar_on_id ON bar USING btree (id);","See server log for query details.",,,,"CREATE INDEX CONCURRENTLY index_foo_on_created_at ON foo USING btree (created_at);",,,"" Here is my process: - Kick off one index build and background 1 second apart, using a queue table to determine what indexes to build and what is finished - When I determine if a index can be built, I first check if there is another already in build on target table before starting another - After the index is built in each workflow, I mark it as built in a queue table I assume that one of the indexes (the earlier transaction) is building and taking so long that several finished indexes end up waiting, and there is perhaps a limit to that? Any insight appreciated. Thanks, Jeremy
Commits
-
Fix deadlock hazard in CREATE INDEX CONCURRENTLY
- fb7b43903e91 9.6.7 landed
- 82f1c3b7d1e0 9.5.11 landed
- 6d2a9ae0ed17 10.2 landed
- 54eff5311d7c 11.0 landed
- 47a3a1317873 9.4.16 landed