Re: BUG #19483: pg_upgrade fails with orphan records in pg_init_priv catalog table

> I have a more pressing concern: has any performance testing been
> done on this?  It looks like it'd be absolutely catastrophic for
> pg_dump performance on databases with lots of objects.
>
> The implementation direction I'd been vaguely imagining was for
> pg_dump's buildACLCommands() to drop any AclItems that contain
> dangling role references (ie, numeric OIDs where a role name
> should be).  If the given role name contains any non-digit
> characters then it's certainly not dangling, so most of the time
> this'd be a very cheap check.  However, if somebody does
>
>         CREATE USER "007";
>         GRANT ALL ON TABLE mi6_operations TO "007";
>
> we mustn't get fooled by that.  The backend is doing us no favors by
> not making numeric OIDs visibly different from all-digit role names
> in AclItems.  In HEAD I'd advocate fixing that on the server side
> (as attached), but we can't assume that a back-branch server has such
> a fix.  What we could do with an old server is issue a query (once per
> pg_dump run) to collect all the valid all-digit role names, which
> should surely be a short list in most databases, and then filter
> against that within buildACLCommands().

I see the approach and it's a valid concern. I can create a v5 to
comply with your suggestion and can create a new patch to be applied
to the current HEAD.

After preparing the v5 I'm going to create a new CF to be patched to
HEAD since this fix will be backpatched.

Regards,
Demir.