Re: Optimze usage of immutable functions as relation

Aleksandr Parfenov <asp437@gmail.com> writes:
> [ funcscan_plan_optimizer_v4.patch ]

A small note here --- this would be noticeably cleaner if removal of
the no-longer-needed function RTE were done using the dummy-relation
infrastructure I proposed in

https://commitfest.postgresql.org/20/1827/

Maybe we should get that done first and then come back to this.

I'm a bit suspicious of the premise of this though, because it's
going to result in a single call of a function being converted
into possibly many calls, if the RTE is referenced in a lot of
places.  Even if the function is immutable so that those calls
get evaluated at plan time not run time, it's still N calls not
one, which'd be bad if the function is expensive.  See e.g.

https://www.postgresql.org/message-id/flat/CAOYf6edujEOGB-9fGG_V9PGQ5O9yoyWmTnE9RyBYTGw%2BDq3SpA%40mail.gmail.com

for an example where we're specifically telling people that
they can put a function into FROM to avoid multiple evaluation.
This patch breaks that guarantee.

A possible fix for this is to do eval_const_expressions() on
function RTE expressions at this stage (and then not need to
do it later), and then pull up only when we find that the
RTE expression has been reduced to a single Const.  I'm not
sure whether invoking eval_const_expressions() so early
would create any issues.  But if it can be made to work, this
would eliminate quite a lot of the ad-hoc conditions that
you have in the patch now.

			regards, tom lane