Re: [bug fix] pg_rewind takes long time because it mistakenly copies data files

On Mon, Feb 26, 2018 at 08:13:02AM +0000, Tsunakawa, Takayuki wrote:
> From: Michael Paquier [mailto:michael@paquier.xyz]
>> Your patch is able to fix that.  I have also checked that after diverging
>> the promoted server with more data and inserting data on the old primary
>> then the correct set of blocks from the tablespace is fetched as well by
>> pg_rewind.  This patch also behaves correctly when creating a new relation
>> on the promoted server as it copies the whole relation. In short your patch
>> looks good to me.
> 
> How quick, I was surprised.  Thank you so much!  I'd be glad if you could be the reviewer in CF:
> 
> https://commitfest.postgresql.org/17/1542/

Sure.

>> Creating a test case for this patch would be nice, however this needs a
>> bit of work so as the tablespace map can be used with pg_basebackup and
>> PostgresNode.pm (or use raw pg_basebackup commands in pg_rewind tests):
>> - PostgresNode::init_from_backup needs to be able to understand extra
>> options given by caller for pg_basebackup.
>> - RewindTest::create_standby should be extended with extra arguments given
>> for previous extension.
>> :(
> 
> That sounds difficult from your way of saying... but this may be a
> good opportunity to look into the TAP tests. 

Anything like that would be work only for HEAD I think as that's a bit
of refactoring.  And indeed it could give you a good introduction to the
TAP facility.
--
Michael