Re: mysterious difference in speed when combining two queries with OR

On 23 Apr 2008, at 9:23AM, Hans Ekbrand wrote:

> I cannot understand why the following two queries differ so much in  
> execution time (almost ten times)
>
> Query A (two queries)
>
> select distinct moment.mid from moment,timecard where parent = 45  
> and (pid=17 and timecard.mid = moment.mid) order by moment.mid;
> select distinct moment.mid from moment,timecard where parent = 45  
> and (pbar = 0) order by moment.mid;
>
> Query B (combining the two with OR)
>
> select distinct moment.mid from moment,timecard where parent = 45  
> and ((pid=17 and timecard.mid = moment.mid) or (pbar = 0)) order by  
> moment.mid;
>
> $ time psql -o /dev/null -f query-a.sql fektest
>
> real    0m2.016s
> user    0m1.532s
> sys     0m0.140s
>
> $ time psql -o /dev/null -f query-b.sql fektest
>
> real    0m28.534s
> user    0m1.516s
> sys     0m0.156s
>
> I have tested this in two different computers with different amount of
> RAM, fast or slow CPU, and the difference is persistent, almost ten
> times.
>
> I should say that this is on postgresql 7.4.16 (debian stable).
>
> Can query B be rewritten so that it would execute faster?

Try
select distinct moment.mid from moment,timecard where parent = 45 and  
(pid=17 and timecard.mid = moment.mid) order by moment.mid
union all
select distinct moment.mid from moment,timecard where parent = 45 and  
(pbar = 0) order by moment.mid;
-- 
Regards
Theo