Re: full featured alter table?

Reynard Hilman <reynardmh@lightsky.com>

From: Reynard Hilman <reynardmh@lightsky.com>
To:
Cc: pgsql-general@postgresql.org
Date: 2003-06-13T17:05:32Z
Lists: pgsql-general
>OK, so how do we handle things like converting a varchar to a timestamp 
>with time zone?  What if one of the rows has invalid date syntax?  Do we 
>convert the column anyway, or throw the whole change out with an error?
>
being a developer instead of DBA makes me think little about the danger 
of losing data when you change column type. But, I think you're right, 
very BAD things could happen with your data if the database silently 
convert / truncate your data when you change the column type.
As far as I remember when working with Oracle, it allows you to change 
the data as long as you don't lose or corrupt your data. So, for 
example, changing varchar(20) to varchar(40) should be ok, but the 
reverse might not be ok. It'd be nice if it allows you to change the 
type from varchar(40) to varchar(20) if you don't have any data that is 
larger than varchar(20). I don't know how much complexity that will add, 
though. well that's just some idea from me.

- reynard